What's inside
As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases. This post may contain affiliate links at no extra cost to you.
What we cover
Identify the anchor before removing it
A damaged drywall anchor may be loose, stripped, broken off below the wall surface, or spinning in its hole. The right removal method depends on what is left behind. First remove the screw with a screwdriver or drill set to low speed. Press firmly and stop if the screw spins without backing out; continued spinning can enlarge the hole and make the anchor harder to grip.
Look at the anchor’s head and the surrounding wall. Plastic expansion anchors often pull out with pliers. Self-drilling plastic or metal anchors have a wide, threaded head that may unscrew. Toggle and molly anchors have parts behind the drywall, so pulling hard on the front can tear the paper face or break out a larger section.
If the anchor is supporting a shelf, cabinet, or other heavy item, take that load off before working. Check for wiring and plumbing before drilling or cutting near the hole. A stud finder can help locate framing, but it does not confirm what is directly behind a particular spot.
Choose the least destructive method
| Anchor condition | First method to try | Main trade-off |
|---|---|---|
| Plastic anchor protruding from the wall | Grip and pull with needle-nose pliers | Quick, but pulling can lift drywall paper |
| Threaded self-drilling anchor | Back it out slowly with a screwdriver | Usually tidy; a stripped head may resist removal |
| Anchor flush with the wall | Press it into the cavity or cut the rim off | Leaves a patchable hole or a small piece inside the wall |
| Toggle or molly anchor | Remove its screw, then let the rear piece fall into the wall | Often enlarges the opening and needs a patch |
Pull out a protruding plastic anchor
For an anchor that sticks out far enough to grip, use needle-nose pliers. Hold the pliers close to the wall, then pull straight out with steady pressure. Avoid rocking the anchor side to side: that movement can crush the gypsum core and widen the hole. If the anchor will not move, try turning it slightly while pulling.
When the anchor is flush or recessed, thread a screw into it by two or three turns, leaving enough screw exposed to grip. Pull the screw gently with pliers. Do not drive the screw all the way in; it can expand the anchor and make it tighter. Stop if the drywall surface starts to bulge or tear. For occasional household repairs, ordinary pliers are usually sufficient; needle-nose pliers are a useful low-cost option if you do not have a pair.
Back out threaded anchors
A self-drilling anchor is designed to screw into drywall, so try reversing that motion. Fit a hand screwdriver or drill bit snugly in the head and turn counterclockwise. If using a cordless drill, select low speed and keep the tool straight. High speed can strip the head, spin the anchor, or chew up the drywall around it. A hand screwdriver gives better control when the head is already damaged.
If the drive recess is stripped, do not keep forcing a bit that slips. For a metal anchor with a raised rim, grip the rim with locking pliers and turn it counterclockwise. Another option is to use a rotary tool or hacksaw blade to cut a slot in the head, then back it out with a flathead screwdriver. Wear eye protection when cutting metal, and protect the wall from the tool. A cut that slips can gouge the paper face.
Handle flush, broken, and toggle anchors
If a plastic anchor is flush and pulling it risks tearing the wall, push it just below the surface with a narrow screwdriver or punch. Do not hammer hard. The aim is to recess the anchor, not break through the back of the drywall. You can then fill and sand the small opening.
For a metal anchor that cannot be unscrewed, cut off only the projecting rim with a sharp utility knife or carefully controlled rotary tool, then press the remaining sleeve into the cavity. Some anchors are too substantial to press in; in that case, remove the damaged drywall around the anchor and patch the opening rather than drilling blindly into the wall.
With a toggle anchor, remove the screw first. A spring toggle’s wings usually fall into the hollow wall when released; they are not normally retrievable through the small hole. A molly anchor may stay in place. If it will not come out cleanly, cut or press its collar below the surface. Do not yank on the collar: the force can tear a much larger flap of drywall.
When a drill helps—and when it does not
A drill can remove an anchor head, but it is not the best first tool for a damaged anchor. If drilling is necessary, start with a bit only slightly larger than the anchor’s inner opening, use low speed, and stop as soon as the head or sleeve releases. A general-purpose drill bit set is adequate for occasional repairs; buy a specialized set only if you regularly work with metal fasteners or need cleaner, repeatable cuts.
Do not use an impact driver for this job. Its repeated blows make it harder to control and can enlarge the hole or damage the wall. A hammer drill is also unnecessary for ordinary drywall; its hammer action is intended for masonry. If a bit catches, the anchor spins, or the wall starts crumbling, stop and switch to pliers, a hand tool, or a larger repair.
Patch the hole and choose the next fastener
Brush away loose dust and paper. For a small hole, apply lightweight spackle or joint compound, let it dry according to the label, then sand lightly and touch up the paint. A shallow hole may need one coat; a ragged or larger opening can take two or more. If the paper face is torn, trim loose edges first and seal exposed brown paper with a suitable primer before applying compound. Otherwise, moisture can make the paper bubble.
Do not put a new anchor into the same enlarged hole unless its packaging specifies a suitable hole size and the surrounding drywall is sound. For a light object, move the fastener a few inches to intact drywall and use an anchor rated for the load. For a heavy or frequently stressed item, fasten into a stud or use a mounting method designed to spread the load. A patched hole restores the surface; it does not restore the wall’s original holding strength.